Why Dumbo Should Have Been A Sequel Instead Of A Remake

WATCH BOX OFFICE MOVIES FOR FREE


Why Dumbo Should Have Been A Sequel Instead Of A Remake

The following contains SPOILERS for the new live action Dumbo.

Dumbo won the box office this past weekend, but it did so with less than impressive numbers. The movie performed similarly with critics. The film has received slightly more negative reviews than positive ones, but critics are split almost in half. Either way, most positive reviews aren't glowing and most negative ones aren't too damning. As one of those who had a slightly positive view of Dumbo, I liked so many aspects of it that I wish it was better, and I think it could have been if it had followed its true calling and just been a straight sequel rather than a remake.

If you've seen Dumbo, then you know that most of the movie is essentially a sequel already. The events that cover the story of the original animated Dumbo get dispensed with in less than 30 minutes. Considering that the original movie did it in only slightly more than double that time, it makes sense not to waste too much time with it. Once Dumbo is discovered to be a flying elephant, the animated film ends, but that's just the end of Act I for the new movie.

The stuff that's worthy of praise in Dumbo almost exclusively comes from the latter two-thirds of the movie. You get the utterly insane "Evil Walt Disney" villain played by Michael Keaton. You get Eva Green, who is awesome because she's Eva Green. You get Tim Burton's take on "Pink Elephants on Parade," which is a thing I didn't even know I cared about. You get Colin Farrell being "adorable dad," which is his perfect position in Disney movies.

The biggest problem that Dumbo has is that it has trouble letting all of these ideas breathe because it has to dedicate a significant portion of its run time to the original story of Dumbo.

This is pretty much unnecessary and could have been overcome quite easily. The fact is that while Dumbo is certainly a story we all know, unless you've seen the film recently, odds are all you really remember about it is, "There's an elephant that can fly." That's actually all you need to know. If you do remember more, you certainly don't need to see it again.

Imagine if the new Dumbo opened exactly as it did, with Colin Farrell's Holt Farrier coming back from war, only this time, instead of Danny DeVito's Max Medici putting him in charge of the elephants before Dumbo is born, Medici tells Farrier that he's really happy Farrier is back, because the circus has a new star that needs to be taken care of, and Farrier is just the man to trust with the job. Dumbo flew for the crowd for the first time last night and word has already begun to spread. That's all we really need to know. Any additional info can be conveyed through dialogue with the other circus performers.

We didn't need to see anything of the original plot in this movie. I have no particular love for the original Dumbo, but there isn't anything I think the new version did better. The "Baby Mine" sequence is an emotional moment in the animated film, but it felt like it was being included in the remake simply because it was the sort of things fan expected. It was tacked on.

Now the movie can jump straight into the new material. The 20 minutes we just saved can be used to dig a little deeper into the rest of the story. We could get to know some of these characters a little better, as that was one of the big things missing from this new version of the story. Farrier's kids are important parts of Dumbo's life, but beyond, "Milly likes science," what do we really know about them?

I had a similar problem back when I first saw Disney's Maleficent. The film surprised the hell out of me by turning the story of the mistress of all evil into a rape revenge story. Needless to say, I did not see that coming. I found both the beginning and end of the movie to be quite good, but in the middle the story of Maleficent took a back seat because we had to tell the story of Sleeping Beauty, because clearly the feeling was it needed to happen. This slowed the movie to a crawl.

The idea behind these remakes is that people love these classic Disney stories, and the live-action versions allow fans to experience them in new ways that honestly weren't possible until recently. While that may be true, what if we looked at it from another angle? Because these stories are so well loved, we don't need to see them again since we know them incredibly well. However, that doesn't mean we don't need to want to see the characters again.

Because we don't need to see these movies again, but we love the characters all the same, sequels are the way to go. Take the animated original as a given, and then come up with a live action sequel that will give us something fresh and new. It won't work with every Disney property, of course. A live-action sequel to Aladdin rather than the remake we're getting would have to include somebody trying to recreate Robin Williams version of that character, and nobody wants that. But if even just a few of these movies went the sequel route, it would at least change things up a bit and let the remakes feel a bit fresher when they did happen.

Of all the live-action fairy tale movies that Disney is releasing this year, I'm actually looking forward to Maleficent: Mistress of Evil above them all. Because the film is a sequel to a movie that never had a Disney animated sequel, the story will almost certainly be entirely original. It's not going to feel like it owes anybody anything and won't need to include scenes that fans want to see new versions of, but will instead just get to tell its own story. i can only hope it's willing to take some of the same risks the previous film did.

Dumbo would have benefited greatly by simply committing to being the sequel it largely was anyway. Trying to be both things in order to make fans happy only prevented the film from being its own thing and flying on its own.





Clerks 3 Isn't Happening Because Of One Cast Member




The Black Widow Movie Has Its Director - CINEMABLEND . 10 minutes ago. Black Widow has been a major player in the Marvel Cinematic Universe since being introduced in Iron Man 2, from being one of the founding Avengers to helping Steve Rogers expose HYDRA's existence within S.H.I.E.L.D.
The 'Black Widow' Movie Has its Director - Pop Culture Uncovered




"We reject in the strongest possible terms the decision to pander to local laws and censor Rocketman for the Russian market, a move we were unaware of until today," John and the filmmakers




The convention runs from April 11-15, and it's where fans will absolutely be learning more about what's coming from the future of Star Wars.However, since the full schedule has been revealed
Our Favorite Memories of the Release of Star Wars: The




Subscribe To The Rise Of Skywalker Trailer Has Been Watched A Record-Breaking Number Of Times Updates close Subscribe To The Rise Of Skywalker Trailer Has Been Watched A Record-Breaking Number Of
The Rise Of Skywalker Trailer Has Been Watched A Record




Ralph Breaks The Internet End Credits Scenes: What Happens, And Why They're Great Want to know how Ralph Breaks The Internet closes the film, courtesy of its post-credits scenes? Read on to find out.
Ralph Breaks the Internet - Wikipedia




5th Update, Early Saturday AM: With chart It's still a great weekend at the box office here, with both Universal's Mamma Mia!Here We Go Again and Sony's Equalizer 2 both over-performing
Will Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again Win The Box Office This Weekend?



Into The Spider-Verse Considered Introducing Audiences To




'Bad Times at the El Royale' director Drew Goddard kept costs low by taking a pay cut — and convincing stars like Chris Hemsworth, Jeff Bridges and Jon Hamm to do the same.
The Bad Times At El Royale Cast Took Pay Cuts To Be In The Movie




Kelly Clarkson's 'Greatest Showman' cover is out! Listen to 'Never Enough' now "The Greatest Showman: Reimagined" drops Friday, but there's no need to wait to hear the singer belt out her cover
The Greatest Showman gets new covers album featuring Pink




NBA Sports Talk: The field vs the Golden State Warriors who you taking Do you trust Chris Paul to stay healthy in the Playoffs Can the Houston Rockets beat the Warriors in a 7 game series How fractured is the Golden State Warriors locker room What would be the best fit for Kevin Durant Kevin Durant amp Kyrie Irving San Antonio Spurs run of
Land of Doom DVD Review • Home Theater Forum




Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom has finally made its way to theaters in the U.S. and we need to talk about that absolutely insane ending The movie has been playing overseas for several weeks
Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom Ending Explained | Collider
collider.com/jurassic-world-fallen-kingdom-ending-explained/
With Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom now in theaters, we dig into that bonkers ending and try to explain what it might mean for Jurassic World 3.
The 'Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom' Ending Explained




What others are saying Take a look at the character poster for Max Medici played by Danny DeVito. A young elephant, whose oversized ears enable him to fly, helps save a struggling circus, but when the circus plans a new venture, Dumbo and his friends discover dark secrets beneath its shiny veneer.
'Dumbo' Falls Short of Box-Office Expectations but Still




According to THR, the film's latest test screenings outperformed the first Deapdool movie from 2016 […] Deadpool 2 Reportedly Outscored First Film In Recent Test Screenings
Deadpool 2 reportedly tests well at screenings; has 'secret




"Artist Says Kendrick Lamar Video for 'Black Panther' Song Stole Her Work" by ROBIN POGREBIN via NYT Lina Iris Viktor alleges that the music video for "All the Stars" from the soundtrack
One Artist Claims That The Kendrick Lamar Video For 'All The


i can only imagine full movie streaming
disney movie streaming service
best movie streaming app
uncle drew movie streaming
movie streaming gb usage
zero movie streaming online
how do movie streaming sites make money
movie streaming uk legal
movie streaming monthly subscription
movie streaming iphone
amazon movie streaming
elf movie streaming
movie streaming rental
xfinity movie streaming
hd movie streaming sites
worst witch movie streaming
movie streaming download
movie streaming hd reddit
movie streaming laws
best worst movie streaming vostfr
movie streaming options
movie streaming programs
movie streaming best websites
movie streaming new releases
movie streaming link
movie streaming royalties
movie streaming devices
kedarnath movie streaming
hd movie streaming free
movie streaming box
movie streaming live
movie streaming free online
free movie streaming 123
where is the wife movie streaming
best sites for movie streaming reddit
good movie streaming sites
youtube free movie streaming
movie streaming us free
is goosebumps movie streaming
that thing you do full movie streaming
free movie streaming yahoo answers
super troopers 2 full movie streaming
does google have a movie streaming service
how to watch movie streaming
john wick 3 full movie streaming
online hindi movie streaming
would you rather movie streaming
indian movie streaming
movie streaming australia
everyday movie streaming
chef movie streaming
columbus movie streaming
movie streaming deutsch
nonton movie streaming
zero dark thirty full movie streaming
loro movie streaming
why did i get married full movie streaming
movie streaming reviews
live movie streaming sites
movie streaming eng
paid movie streaming sites
movie streaming hardwarezone
it movie streaming
movie streaming online indoxxi
equalizer 2 full movie streaming
what is movie streaming
movie streaming bandwidth
goosebumps movie streaming
best worst movie documentary streaming
movie streaming for free
movie streaming emulator
iron will movie streaming
lion movie streaming
movie streaming tagalog
john wick full movie streaming
scary movie streaming
movie streaming high quality
movie streaming hindi
xbox 360 movie streaming sites
new movie streaming free
movie streaming quality
quiet place movie streaming
#watchthemoonrise #america #filmtavsiyesi #watchos4 #funnytime #watchfamily #FreeMovies #blackiflix #blackqueen #blackking #americanflag #blackbusiness #tvroomdesign #4thofjuly #watchnerds #Movies #blackenterprise #filmography #hostales #socialstreaming #birdbox #movieaddict #getsome #sandrabullock #independenceday #filmizle #melaninmagic #watchswag #watchcandy #moviesstreaming #blacksocialmedia #saladetv #watchmovies #blavity #WatchMovies #bff #Serialemetitrashqip #filmlover #TVSHow #Filma #HostalCASAMXalameda #watchphoto #slay #Filmametitrashqip #watchhill #blacksuccess #Zgerdhiu #filmyorumu #watchwomen #watchalert #watchbrandname #watchpornid #watchenthusiasts #watchmaniac #TvSeries #watchdose #netflix #watchmvmt #WatchUsRise #watchcrazy #Filma24 #fireworks #fourthofjuly #WatchJunkie #watchobsessed #Qesh #watchblogger #murica #melanin #movietime #firecrackers #watchluxus #watchestyle #merica #putitinreverseterry #CASAMXhostales #watchful #WatchRoss #watchuswork #Seriale #watchquiz #SomosTuConexi #blacktech #netflixturkiye #watchingthesunset #holiday #blackhistory365 #watchtattoo

0 comments:

Post a Comment